David Black, a prison officer, a public servant, was murdered this week. [i] It was an appalling crime but it’s just not plausible to say so without saying the same of earlier similar acts. No doubt the perps. will say that that they are “fighting” for Irish freedom from Britain or for Irish “unification” and that what they did was part of a continuing struggle dating back to the early 20th century or earlier. [ii] In Ireland over the years we’ve adopted a number of pivotal moments, glorifying violence before a moment and condemning violence after it, just as SF and others now treat the Good Friday agreement and the peace “process”. They seek to portray themselves as unlike today’s killers. They want to do what has been done before: be part of a new establishment which condemns the latest political murders. It’s a depressing pattern. As the various claimants to be the heirs polish their boots for centenary marches, [iii] it might do some good if a few of them at least realised that they had plausibility problems.
Tag Archives: plausibility
- November 2, 2012 – 9:04 pm
- Posted in Uncategorized
- Tagged Britain, british, catholic, centenary, condemnation, controversy, culture, david black, debate, Fianna Fail, Fine Gael, freedom, good friday agreement, history, integrity, Ireland, Irish, irish times, nationalism, northern ireland, peace process, plausibility, political communication, political murder, prison officer, public controversy, public discussion, public servant, religion, sf, Sinn Fein, struggle, unification